On Trinity Sunday, June 20, 1886, seven people gathered to form an Episcopal Mission in Northport. Their meeting place was the loft of the newly-formed Edward Thompson Publishing Company on Woodbine Avenue. It was the first, but by no means the last time that village and church were to act in concert, one contributing to the other as both developed together. Edward Thompson of that firm, and his associate, James Cockcroft, were both wardens; Mr. Cockroft provided the lot on Main Street where the church was built, largely because of an influx of Episcopalians into the Village (young southern attorneys hired by Mr. Thompson to work in his legal publishing business).
The cornerstone of the current church was set on June 16, 1889 and the first service in the new church was given on Christmas Eve of 1889. In 1893 a pipe organ was installed and in 1903 a vested choir. Also in 1903 the parish began construction of a parish hall (then called a guildhall) next to the Church.
By 1909, Northport had its own water service, eliminating the need for outhouses (‘cold and uncomfortable in winter, and hot and oppressive in the summer’, one account says) and Trinity’s parish hall was being used for “community events and fellowship” and had doubled in size.
Among such events, recalls longtime villager, Henrietta VanSiclen, was the appearance at Trinity of the great opera star, Enrico Caruso, one of a number of singers invited by a wealthy Centerport socialite and parishioner, Countess May deBrabant, to sing at the Church. Mrs. VanSiclen was “about 10 years old at the time and I remember hearing Caruso at the Church, he sang so loud that you couldn’t sit in the Church and listen; you had to go outside and then he sounded just fine.”
In 1913, Trinity parishioners were among residents of Northport and East Northport agreed to form a public library. Mrs. Marian Meany remembers moving into a little house on Laurel Avenue across the street from what was then Northport High School and is now Northport Middle School, with her husband Norman, who in the 1920’s came to manage the Northport Lumber Co. and became church treasurer and choirmaster. The high school had just graduated its first class the year before. By the 1930’s, Trinity had added two rooms and a kitchen to the parish hall and added a chancel, pulpit and lectern to the sanctuary. It was in the depths of the Depression and the Thompson Publishing Co., which had figured so largely in the church’s beginning, was gone, sold and relocated in 1935 to Brooklyn. WWII came and in 1944, a major change occurred at Trinity. For the first time since the Church’s inception, women were allowed to vote at annual and special meetings.
In 1948 a house was purchased for use by clergy, and in 1954 St. Bede’s house was bought, renovated, and enlarged.
After the war, Trinity and Northport prospered; Harry Richardson, a mayor during the 1950’s, was a parishioner; Jacob Harvin, a warden also served on the village board as trustee. The suburban population growth, experienced throughout central and western Long Island, sparked new construction at Trinity, including a new parish hall. The Church’s parishioners continue to be active in the community.
With the beginning of the 1960s Trinity commenced another wave of steady improvements, including the enlargement of the main worship space, the construction of the Church School (the Weaver building) in 1963, the purchase of a rectory in 1965 (sold later during the 1990s), the addition of an undercroft in 1967, and the construction of Houghton Hall (named for a former Warden; completed in 1976).
THE RECTORS OF TRINITY EPISCOPAL CHURCH
| The Rev. Edgar L. Sanford | 1887 – 1890 |
| The Rev. S. B. Gallendet | 1890 |
| The Rev. William Holden | 1891 – 1901 |
| The Rev. Charles E. Cragg | 1901 – 1910 |
| The Rev. A. N. Merrick | 1910 – 1912 |
| The Rev. John Tilley | 1913 – 1917 |
| The Rev. George S. Mullen | 1917 – 1919 |
| The Rev. William Walker | 1919 – 1920 |
| The Rev. William Nicolls | 1921 – 1922 |
| The Rev. Creighton Spencer Mounsey | 1922 – 1932 |
| The Rev. William R. Otto | 1933 – 1936 |
| The Rev. Hedley J. Williams | 1936 – 1940 |
| The Rev. Harold Durando | 1941 – 1943 |
| The Rev. Walter F. Tuhey | 1944 – 1945 |
| The Rev. David J. Williams | 1945 – 1952 |
| The Rev. Graham H. Walworth | 1952 – 1986 |
| The Rev. William C. Bergmann | 1988 – 1992 |
| The Rev. Kevin A. Barry | 1994 – 1999 |
| The Rev. Eric J. Weaver (Asst. Priest) | 2000 – 2010 |
| The Rev. Lynne A. Grifo (Interim Priest) | 2010 – 2011 |
| The Rev. Michael E. Bartolomeo | 2011 – 2022 |
| The Rev. Andrew Garnett | 2022 – |
